Oakhurst Diner

Reviews about Oakhurst Diner

• 1 / 5

  By Shannon Jacovino
  I drive into Red Hook, NY from CT with my daughter several times a year. We often pass through Millerton in the early evening on our drives and stop at the Oakhurst Diner for dinner. The Diner from the outside looks like the most comfy and inviting spot. I really wanted to like this place and I've given it far too many chances because I love the way it looks, the menu is interesting and eclectic and I've have had a couple of decent meals there. But the ever so hip staff are always uninviting and unfriendly, which is something I might be able to get past if the food were consistently good, but it's not. The only consistent thing at this diner is the wait staff's bad attitude.
  
  I made what will be my last stop there tonight. Our meal came out fast, within less than 10 minutes of our ordering it, because none of it was fully cooked. I had Eggs Benedict with raw English muffins and hash browns that tasted like they had been sitting in old grease on the grill for a couple of days. My daughter ordered a corn dog with a salad from the kid's menu. The corn dog was ice cold and inedible.I told the staff about this and after offering no apology, they informed me that they were only going to charge me $3.50 for the sad little side salad that came as part of her disgusting meal, as if they were actually doing me a favor.
  October 09, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Rose H
  I loved this diner. Run by women, so clean, efficient, and interesting menu. My omelet was perfectly cooked. Even the coffee was great, which is rare in a diner.
  October 06, 2016
• 3 / 5

  By Amy Uong
  It's not your typical Jersey diner fare, but it does offer decent dishes. If it going to serve a banh mi, it needs to use a nice light, crispy shell and airy French baguette.
  September 14, 2016